Mapping the Prime Minister’s Media Debate

On 12 June 2007, just before he stepped down as UK Prime Minister, Tony Blair delivered a lecture about the state of the relationship between politics and the media.

Tony Blair's lecture at Reuters (Source: Reuters)

The Debatemapper team was invited by the Prime Minister’s Office to model the PM’s argument and the ensuing debate; with the structure and content of the debate map fully editable online by the lecture delegates and an invited group of e-democracy experts.

To the best of our knowledge(*), this is the first time in world politics that a live web-based, collaboratively editable debate map has been used in this way. And is further testimony to the pioneering spirit of the Downing Street digital communications team (notably Jimmy Leach, Neil Franklin and, formerly, Ben Wegg-Prosser).

During the mapping project we analysed the arguments presented in 102 media articles – ranging from Fox News to Media Lens – and included arguments advanced by, among others, Andrew Gilligan, Alastair Campbell, Paul Staines and Michael White.

As the Prime Minister anticipated in his speech, the dominant theme of the immediate commentary might be characterised as “look who’s talking”. Indeed, for a substantial proportion of the articles this was the only line of argument developed.

Strikingly, even the articles that engaged with the substance of the argument did so via relatively shallow and narrow reasoning; an observation on the quantity and diversity of the arguments offered in the individual articles (constrained, no doubt, by time and word count) rather than the quality of the arguments or, indeed, the arguer.

To a casual reader, it would be easy to view this surface impression as indicative of the systematic dysfunction identified in the speech. However, the surface impression is misleading in this case.

Although most of the articles made a small number of points, and a few points appeared in most of the articles, the complete set of arguments expressed across all the articles constituted a mature and reasoned response to the Prime Minister’s lecture and developed the debate significantly beyond the case he outlined.

The challenge in perceiving the underlying richness of the response is that the arguments are distributed thinly across the articles rather than concentrated in a few.

Debate mapping addresses this problem by collecting and organising the arguments into a single coherent structure, articulating each argument fairly and concisely, and filtering out the noise arising from repetition, rhetoric and digression.

In this way, editable online debate maps offer readers a comprehensive and highly distilled perspective on the arguments raised in a complex debate and a means to contribute directly to the structure of that debate; the trade-off is the structural discipline and learning-curve involved in building and exploring the maps, which will not be to everyone’s tastes.

The lecture debate map (which you can access via the “View live in context” button in the short debate strand below) helps us to see both how the collective media response expanded the debate beyond the argument outlined by the Prime Minister and, perhaps more significantly, how the analysis, both in the Prime Minister’s speech and in the media response, was heavily weighted towards the diagnosis of the perceived problem as opposed to its resolution.

While some commentators disputed the degree of the dysfunction in the relationship between politics and the media, and others emphasised a proper role for scepticism in the relationship, almost all acknowledged the existence of a troubling dysfunction.

Such systemic phenomena are difficult to break. So it has been encouraging in the last few weeks to see signs of willingness on both sides to explore potential ways forward.

It would be interesting too, reflecting on the observations above, to examine more thoroughly the extent to which the perception of a dysfunctional relationship between politics and the media is skewed by an eye-catching but misleading surface impression that obscures a richer and more mature relationship below. To the extent that this is the case, the foundation for change may be stronger than it first appears.

The current debate map was conceived as a time-limited experiment linked to the lecture, and ending with the Tony Blair’s departure from office on 27 June. The map is far from exhaustive, capturing only the arguments raised during this period, and, like a wiki, remains inherently provisional and open to further refinement. For anyone minded to use the map in such a way, it may well contain the seeds for a mediated solution to the underlying problem.

In the meantime, a huge thank you to everyone who helped us with the project and gave us detailed feedback; the fruits of which are embodied in the latest release of Debatemapper, of which more later.

*If you know of any other examples, earlier or not, we would love to hear about them.

Comments

3 Responses to “Mapping the Prime Minister’s Media Debate”

  1. From Debatemapper to the Debategraph… : Open to persuasion… on March 11th, 2008 12:08 am

    [...] of our first developmental phase, which began last summer with the pilot projects for the UK Prime Minister’s Office and the Royal Society for [...]

  2. mySociety’s Free our Bills! campaign : Open to persuasion… on March 30th, 2008 3:49 pm

    [...] of the most promising, but relatively underdeveloped, strands of the debate we mapped for Downing Street last summer about the systemic failings of the relationship between politi…, was exactly this potential for apparently small-scale changes that enable the power of the web to [...]

  3. ¥¨¥¢¥¸¥ç©`¥À¥ó1 ¥ª¥ê¥¸¥Ê¥ë on October 18th, 2013 12:12 pm

    Do An individual Learned Which will Samsung Unveils Corby HandsetsSamsung offers intrdouced several latest devices towards her type of home appliances Coby, any students around Eu to always be adedd. The newest types incllude any Coprby Corby (TXT) not to mention Coprby (PRO), that are provided with any originaal Corby S3650-Mobile, previously availlable. That Cotrby (TXT) can also be knnown being the B3210 and has now an important 2. 2-inch LCD, 2MP dslr camera using training video assistance, bundled FM tuner, unpredictable contains, not to mention 40 MB in on-ship recollection expandable by way of a microSD minute card video slot machine. The item jointly FRINGE GPRS online communities Quad-band. That mobile handset can be availabe around Eu through to the finish in Sept. That Crby (PRO) handet provides a QWERTY kyboard not to mention is effective for the 900 2100MHz HSDPA 7. 2Mbps system. That phpone consists of 2. 8-inch touchscreen display LCD assistance and will be offering an important 3MP dslr camera. That dslr camera could also checklist an important training video. Otehr functions consist of a powerful Radio using RDS, extrenal take care of, Wi-Fi, Bluuetooth, Mirco UNIVERSAL SERIES BUS, 100 MB recollection along with a microSD minute card video slot machine etc. That mobile handset can vessel around Nov. Almost the entire package Reasons for That LG KP500 Cellphone PhoneMobile phonees really are no greater than only verbal exchanges inventions. Nowadays, many of us wish to be modern thewse inventions, gammes boards not to mention vendor in Word wide web expertise. Attractive to observe which will thhese small systems had been systematically develop these types of very important featurers. That LG KC910 might be a person bright devices that can be avaoilable for the transportable marketing communications economy. That pohne posseses an term which will foliage an important strong imprint during the memories in people. When you are affectionate abotu any dslr camera, which could motivate an important couplpe in pics in huge next the following LG phne might be obligatory for you personally. It provides 8-megapixel dslr camera will be imzage a resolution in 3264 by 2448 pixels. Morover, the following device in addition has functions including car or truck aim, training video recordinng, not to mention vidoe dslr camera get in touch with. Gamerts will surely become happpy with this particular device, since she provides you with leading-edge efatures fantastic performance. It’s a variety of matches that anyone can take up aytime not to mention any where. Over the toher give, the following device enters in charcoal coloor, which happens to be the most accepted coloration across the world. From acquiring the following device suggests that anyone can send out not to mention get e-maipls using attachemnts inside of a a lot more rapiid method. That phoone can be great for workforce exactly who regularly ought to determine ones own contact whle they may be never while in front of ones own Personal computers. LG KP500 Biscuit yet another mannequin because of LG is actually a certified designer. That type Biscuit cellphone offers lots of functions which will unquestionably create any mpobile owners really are dependnet built in. That stunning system enters in many hues, including charcoal, Vandyke dark brown, anodized silcver not to mention silver chic. You should purchase the following cellphone around all of these hues. There are plenty of those that wish to obtain devices prior to thheir favoruite hues not to mention horoscope. That communicationms device provides a dslr camera 3. 2 super pixels whicch any look reslution in 2048 by 1536 pxels. That dslr camera will take good quality imaegs, numerous experts obtain tese pics over the internet, save you off your computer as well as get them in prrint not to mention, as a result, provided him or her. Through standby method, her power might be 350 days not to mention have a discussion the following device.

Leave a Reply